Models and methods for automated analytic support of the organization decisions field

E.P. Ilina, I.P. Sinitsyn


The new approach to the computer support of the organization decision making processes is presented. It is based on the relevant results of the authors` earlier works and is aimed at a goal of integration of a new decision into the actual organization decisions system. There are three factors of the organization decisions field heterogeneity that manifest themselves in today organization. They are connected with coexistence of the different decisions classes (programmed and unprogrammed ones), with  the organization and stakeholders goals system incoherence and with difference of expert viewpoints to be used. The special ontological model of organization decisions area with the formal technique of decisions interrelations analysis is created as a base for the decision field harmonization. Its application to the intelligent information technology for organization decision making support is considered. The expert analytic processes for different decisions making stages based on the Diagnostic Value Tree Model are defined. The methods of the conceptualy compromise models and contexts forming for the expert decision making under the multiview expert groups are created. The results of the proposed approach application in the military strategic planning are characterized.

Problems in programming 2017; 3: 113-127


ontological model of the organization decision making area; proactive harmonization of the decisions; heterogeneous decisions system; expert analytic approach; Diagnostic Value Tree; conceptual compromise; intelligent information technology

Full Text:

PDF (Russian)


Frankel E.G. Quality Decision Management – The Heart of Effective Futures-Oriented Management: A Primer for Effective Deci-sion-Based Management. New York: Springer, 2008. 110 p.

Bernus P., Uppington G. Co-ordination of management activities – mapping organisational structure to the decision structure. // Conen W., Neumann G. Coordination Technology for Collaborative Application. Organizations, Processes, and Agents. Lect. Notes Comp. Sci. 1998. N 1364. P. 25–38.

Decision Model and Notation (DMN). Version 1.1. Object Management Group, Inc, 2016. 182 p. [Electronic resourse]. Mode of access:

Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN). Version 2.0 – Object Management Group, 2011. 538 p. [Electronic resourse]. Mode of access: BPMN/2.0/PDF.

Taylor J. An Introduction to Decision Modeling with DMN. Decision Management Solutions. 2016. 12 p.

Matheson J.E. Decision Analysis = Decision Engineering. INFORMS Tutorials in Operations Research, 2005. P. 195–212. [Electronic resourse]. Mode of access:

Calisti M., Greenwood D. Goal-Oriented Autonomic Process Modeling and Execution for Next Generation Networks. Burgess M., Denazis S. (eds.) Modeling Autonomic Communication Environments. Proc. of 3-rd IEEE International Workshop. MACE. 2008. P. 38–50.

Sabatucci L., Ribino P., Lodato C., Lopes S., Cossentino M. GoalSpec: A Goal Speci-fication Language Supporting Adoptivity and Evolution. International Workshop on Engineering Multi-Agent Systems EMAS 2013: Engineering Multi-agent Systems. P. 235–254.

Filipowska A., Hepp M., Kaczmarek M., Markovic I. Organisational Ontology Framework for Semantic Business Process Management. Lect. Notes in Business Information Processing. 2009. Vol. 21. P. 1–12.

Ilina E.P. "Management of quality of organization decisions grounded on formalized corporation knowledge. P1. Ontology of organization decisions" [In Russian] In: Mathematic machines and Systems. 2014. N 1. P 129–142.

Simon H.A. The New Science of Manage-ment Decision. NY: Prentice Hall PTR, 1977. 175 p.

Ilina E.P. Methods and models of the expert analytic using for the decision support organization. P1. Decisions models [In Russian] In: Problems in Programming. 2016. N 1. P. 89–101.

Ilina E.P. Methods and models of the ex-pert analytic using for the decision support organization. P2. Decisions models [In Russian]

In: Problems in Programming. 2016. N 4. P. 66–80.

Ilina E.P., Sinitsyn I.P., Yablokova T.L. "Designing principles of the Intelligent information technology for organization decisions" [In Russian] In: Problems in Programming. 2015. N 2. P. 63–75.

Ilina E.P., Slabospitskaya O.A., Sinitsyn I.P., Yablokova T.L. Computer Support of decision making in the fundamental scien-tific research programs management using the expert methodology [In Russian] Kiev, 2010. 94 p. (Preprint. Kiev. Software Systems Institute of NAS of Ukraine, 2010).

Computer program "Program complex for forming and intelligent generalization of the multicriterial expert values". – User guidance [In Russian] – Certificate of copyright

N 31357 14.12.2009. – Kiev: State department of Intelligent property of MESU.

Ilina E.P. Representation and Using of "Value Tree" Model in onthologies of participatory decision making [In Russian] In: Proc.

Of Sevastopol National University of Nuclear Energy and Industry. 2008. N 1 (25). P. 110–121.

Ilina E.P. The functions and methods for the modern paradigms of the Delphi method support [In Russian] In: Problems in Programming. 2009. N 1. P. 36–52.

Ilina E.P., Slabospitskaya O.A. The forms, the metrics and the features of the similari-ty relationship between the concepts in expert viewpoints onthologies [In Russian] In: Problems in Programming. 2005. N 4. P. 39–49.

Ilina E.P., Slabospitskaya O.A. Multiagent model for Delphi process performance management of multitour expertise [In Rus-sian] In: Mathematical Machines and Systems. 2012. N 3. P. 103–115.

Ilina E.P., Lysenko A.I., Sinitsyn I.P. The technique of the evaluation of the financial risk connected with the fighting efficiency decreasing of the military formation [In Russian] In: BULLETIN of NTUU KPI. Informatics and control and computer technique. 2006. N 44. P. 76–102.

Ilina E.P. Tasks and methods of analytical support for expert approach in the partici-patory strategic management process [In Russian] In: Problems in Programming. 2006. N 2-3. P. 421–430.

Ilina E.P. The methodological and technological principles for expert monitoring and actualizing of the State Development Programs [In Ukranian] In: Problems in Programming. 2008. N 2-3. P. 438–444.

Ilina E.P., Tasks and models for perspectivity evaluation of planning decisions in life cycle of goal aimed programs [In Russian] In: Reports of XV International Conference Automatics. 2008. Vol. 1. P. 228–231.

Ilina E.P., Slabospitskaya O.A., Sinitsyn I.P., Yablokova T.L. The models of the quality expert analysis for the decisions made under target programming [In Russian] Problems in Programming. 2008. N 4. P. 60–72.

Ilina E.P., Slabospitskaya O.A., Sinitsyn I.P., Yablokova T.L. Models and methods for analytical support for strategic management decision making [In Russian] Problems in Programming. 2012. N 2-3. P. 270–280.


  • There are currently no refbacks.